Chapter 7 - THE MAIN KEY AND THE SAFE KEY
The two keys Catherine placed on the table during the confrontation mattered for another reason.
The main key opened the house.
The smaller brass key opened the document safe inside Catherine’s office.
When she checked the safe after Benjamin left, several folders had been moved.
Nothing obvious was missing.
Then Grace compared scans Catherine had stored years earlier.
The original premarital agreement was present.
So was the recorded deed.
But a recent appraisal was gone.
So was an unsigned home-equity application Catherine had rejected six months earlier.
Benjamin had suggested using the house to fund a business expansion.
Catherine refused.
“I’m not borrowing against my home for your consulting company.”
He had seemed disappointed but accepting.
He had not accepted it.
The lender confirmed Benjamin later contacted them independently and tried to revive the application.
He described himself as a “marital owner with beneficial equity.”
The lender requested proof.
Benjamin sent contractor summaries showing he had invested hundreds of thousands of dollars improving the property.
The numbers came from the same false invoice structure used to pay Margot.
He was trying to create a paper trail showing substantial financial contribution to Catherine’s separate home.
Not enough to automatically make him owner.
But enough, he apparently hoped, to strengthen a claim during divorce negotiations or persuade a lender he had rights he did not actually possess.
The missing appraisal had not disappeared accidentally.
Benjamin needed it.
The house was worth nearly $1.9 million.
Mortgage balance:
Under $400,000.
May you like
That equity was the largest pool of money anywhere near his collapsing finances.
And he had already begun constructing a story in which some of it belonged to him.
